HumanityBioethics

Homosexuality

quick ideas about homosexuality. When is there homosexuality and when is there not? How is homosexuality acquired and how is it overcome?

EspañolEspañol

A. Homosexuality in general

1. What is homosexuality?

Homosexuality is a sexual attraction toward persons of the same sex, that is, between men or between women. Here, in using the word homosexuality, we include both cases, avoiding the words gay and lesbian because of the negative connotation of these two words.

2. Who are not homosexual?

Homosexuality is a delicate situation that must be clarified carefully so as not to make sad mistakes, since any sexual attraction toward the same sex is not a sign of homosexuality. Examples of persons who are not homosexual:
  • People with a greater sensitivity to beauty. They find beauty in both sexes and this attracts them. Discovering beauty in the same sex does not mean homosexuality, since that beauty truly exists and it is normal for it to attract. Authentic homosexuality includes a lack of response to the opposite sex.
  • People with a greater sensitivity to expressions of affection, wherever they come from. This does not mean homosexuality either.
  • People who have thought about or engaged in homosexual acts but only exceptionally. Isolated incidents do not give rise to a firm classification.
  • Adolescents with faults in their process of maturity. These are usually corrected easily, unless the disorientation is encouraged.
  • People who have not practiced the virtue of chastity but are dominated by desire for sexual pleasures and seek them anywhere. They are indifferent to race, age, and sex. This is not homosexuality but an obsession with sex.

3. How is homosexuality acquired?

(A more extensive answer in section C.) The process can be sketched as follows:
  • A traumatic beginning, a troubled environment, psychological pressure..., give rise to a mistaken affective inclination.
  • That affective inclination is not controlled but is allowed to run into disordered sexual acts.
  • The sexual pleasures obtained reinforce the inclination through the desire to obtain them again.

4. How is homosexuality overcome?

(A more extensive answer in section D.) Homosexuality admits of correction, although it is neither easy nor quick, since sexual disorders create addiction. Sometimes it will be necessary to consult a trusted psychiatrist. In general, the following can be recommended:
  • Controlling sexual desires, avoiding repeating them both in reality and in thought, in order to forget the addiction to sex. (This will be more or less costly depending on the degree of involvement; this intense effort is part of the price that must be paid to overcome the problem.)
  • If there have been no sexual disorders, it is only a matter of overcoming the affective inclination by correcting feelings. Constancy and patience will be needed, until the underlying attitudes are gradually forgotten.
  • In any case, homosexual tendencies are better overcome with abundant work (to keep the mind occupied) and with service to others (drawing the heart out of selfishness and loneliness). Feelings of self-pity are counterproductive.
  • It will also help to foster spiritual life, to achieve greater balance and to ask for divine assistance.

B. Homosexuality and illness

1. Is an illness something degrading?

No, no. All men are ill at some point in their lives. Illness is not desirable, but it is inseparable from the human condition. A sick person is not an unworthy being, but a human being who deserves greater care since they are in a delicate situation.

2. Is a person with a defect hateable?

No, no. All men have some defects. There is no perfect human race. Defects are defects and therefore harmful, but human beings remain human even with defects. No one should be hated.

3. Is it indifferent to use sex one way or another?

There are two possibilities:
  • If anything goes in sex and there is no limit, then any sexual use would be correct: homosexual practices, adultery, fornication, sex with minors, etc. According to this view, an intelligent use of sex would be prostitution, since it would have the advantage of providing money.
  • The other possibility is to consider that sex has its own norms and cannot be used in any way or with anyone. This leads to the conclusion most in accord with human nature: sex should only be used by each husband with his wife, open to new life.

4. Is homosexuality a sexual tendency like any other?

Tendencies are not distinguished by being tendencies but by what they incline toward. And they will be good or defective according to what they aim to achieve. For example, there are tendencies toward obesity, theft, music, anger, serenity, the neighbor's wife, suicide, etc. Some are good and others should be controlled.

5. Is homosexuality a good tendency?

Here there are two possible answers:
  • Those who think that sex can be used in any way consider homosexual practices to be correct.
  • Those who accept that sex has its own norms consider the most basic rule to be that it should only be used by a man with a woman. And therefore homosexuality is a tendency that should be corrected or controlled. Obviously this is the reasonable position.

6. Is homosexuality an illness?

Here too there are two possible answers:
  • Those who think that sex can be used in any way consider homosexuality as just another way, and do not wish to be cured nor call it an illness.
  • Those who see that homosexuality is an anomalous tendency compare it with inclinations toward theft, alcohol, gambling... And therefore consider it a vice, a defect, or an illness like gambling addiction or alcoholism.

7. How is it best to consider homosexuality?

  • Considering it a defect or anomaly has the advantage that one will try to correct it and avoid practicing it.
  • Seeing it as good does not solve the problem. And let us not forget that being homosexual is not something enjoyable, but a compulsive psycho-dependency.
  • It is better to consider it an illness because one can look for a way to be cured. And in fact there are psychiatrists who achieve good results.

8. What type of illness is it?

  • Homosexuality is a purely psychological phenomenon and cannot be changed by hormones. Glandular or hormonal factors are not a cause of homosexuality.
  • Homosexuals have normal chromosomes. Genetic or hereditary factors do not cause homosexuality.
  • Homosexuality falls among the so-called neuroses or disorders, in this case sexual. (Other neuroses include for example depressive disorders, phobias, anxiety, gambling addiction, pedophilia...) In fact it can be treated through psychiatry and psychotherapy.

9. Common symptoms of neuroses?

These disorders include doubts, obsessions, insecurities, and inner conflicts. At bottom, these traits are observed:
  • inferiority complex.
  • childishness; desire to attract attention and be approved.
  • mental egocentrism.
  • habit of self-pity; tendency to complain; self-dramatization: poor me!; feeling like a victim.
Great improvement is achieved by breaking the bonds of self-pity.

C. How is homosexuality acquired?

1. Do parents have an influence?

Any parent always influences their children; but each child forges their own life and is responsible for their actions. Homosexuals are responsible for their decisions, even if they have been subjected to influences:
  • The father.- For a boy, feeling valued by his father is essential for his self-confidence as a man. A distant and remote father is a bad influence.
  • The mother.- An overprotective mother may make her son feel less virile, and is also an inconvenient influence, though less important than the father's.

2. Does the environment have an influence?

The relationship with other boys is a more decisive factor. If the boy enters the world of the other boys and becomes one of them, the danger of homosexuality is over. On the other hand, if he feels marginalized, the danger increases. Mockery worsens the situation.

3. Is there personal guilt?

Without a doubt. Every human being is free, and can allow themselves to be swept along by a situation, or make their own way in a hostile environment. For example, the self-perception one has of oneself also has an influence, as does one's capacity for endurance.

4. How does homosexuality become rooted?

The process continues thus:
  • A continuous inferiority complex generates self-pity and self-dramatization, so that one's own ego feels important: How I suffer! My suffering is unique!
  • Repeated self-pity generates a habit and a dependence on that consoling complaint. The maturity of the personality is arrested in those areas where that self-pity takes root. And a pitiful child remains living in the adult, tyrannizing the mind in search of comfort.

5. How does homosexual eroticism arise?

The homosexual process continues in this way:
  • An anxious desire for comfort in another like oneself arises. (A selfish love, like that of one who seeks only sexual pleasures.) Why in another boy? Because of his strong desire to be included in the world of men and to be valued by them.
  • With sexual pleasures a greater dependence is acquired, without the dependence on self-pity and self-dramatization ceasing. Even more pain is sought to feed the self-dramatization, so as to feel more self-pity. Another lover is sought, and another, and another, and none are truly loved because only one's own self is being sought. And relations are broken off in order to keep dramatizing, seeking another.

6. Why is affective maturity blocked in homosexuality?

  • Affective maturity requires going out of oneself, while self-consolation centers thought on oneself, and dependence creates a panic at leaving that situation.
  • It is hard to break out of this loop because self-pity consoles a little, and one fears losing this support against one's inferiority complex.
  • Affectivity remains stuck in that situation which one fears to leave; and instinctive heterosexual feelings are unconsciously blocked and never reach maturity. A self-pitying and complaining child remains in the interior, dominating and repressing everything else, so as not to lose the comfort of self-pity on which one has become dependent.

7. Is it bad to be a compassionate person?

Feeling pity toward someone is good if it leads to providing them some good. But if pity only serves to make one feel good with one's pitying heart, then there is a danger of wishing that person to remain in a bad state, in order to continue feeling the pity that pleases oneself.

8. Is it bad to feel self-pity?

It is not bad if it serves to make greater effort and change the situation, but if one finds comfort in that self-pity one may wish to maintain that state in order to keep obtaining that comfort. The homosexual feels self-pity about his lack of virility, becomes dependent on his self-pity, and without realizing it blocks anything that would deprive him of that comfort. Unconsciously he desires to remain lacking in virility in order to continue feeling sorry for himself. For this reason, healing requires breaking the habit of self-pity, and this breaking is painful.

D. How is homosexuality overcome?

1. Is it better to accept it or is it worth overcoming it?

Even if accepted, homosexuality maintains a far from pleasant tension. Much better to overcome oneself and be freed from that situation.

2. What tensions must be endured?

With more or less variations, some tensions typical in the interior of homosexuals can be mentioned:
  • The heterosexual instincts that struggle to emerge, and the self-pitying child that does not let them grow. Emotional maturity that wishes to surface and infantilism that represses it.
  • The inferiority complex and the desire to overcome it.
  • The compulsive craving for sex and lovers for one's own satisfaction and comfort. And the desire to love truly and not be a slave to sex.
  • The demand for attention and the desire for freedom. Excessive attachment to the mother, and the urge to grow up.
  • The dramatizing self-pity, and the normal desire not to feel like a victim.
  • Difficulty in relating to others, and the strong desire to be accepted and comforted by others.
  • They do not feel like women, nor do they consider themselves among men. One is an adult man, and retains rigid childish attitudes.
The tensions are so many that cured homosexuals often say they have been freed from a very heavy burden.

3. Acceptance cures the tensions

No, no. Accepting homosexuality avoids thinking about the problem and achieves only superficial relief. The tensions remain beneath the surface, since an unnatural situation is maintained. Indeed, tensions are desired so as to self-dramatize and self-console.

4. Is it possible to be cured?

Yes. It is possible to be cured, and in fact there are quite a few persons who have achieved this; and others who have greatly improved. However, if homosexuality is deeply rooted, healing requires a slow process lasting several years. Something similar happens with other neuroses: Phobias and obsessive-compulsive disorders can be cured, but the change is not simple. It is normal for a cure to take three to five years of effort, though this is not a fixed rule and some cases are faster than others.

5. Does marriage cure it?

No, no. Homosexuality is cured when affectivity matures. This is not achieved through marriage.

6. How is homosexuality overcome?

The most effective and proven healing process aims at freeing oneself from the inner self-pitying and complaining child. If it is gradually pushed aside, the instinctive heterosexual affectivity eventually matures and healing takes place.

7. How to proceed?

Some guidelines for treating homosexuality are:
  • Obviously, homosexual contacts that feed the problem must be cut off. Just as a drug addict must give up drugs if they wish to be cured.
  • It is helpful to detect the inner complaining child and gradually eliminate complaints and dramas.
  • It is helpful to detect infantile self-pity and gradually set it aside.

8. A practical way to proceed?

A very interesting way to overcome the inner child is to laugh at it. This way it loses importance. Laughing at oneself helps greatly in overcoming many neuroses. For example:
  • Yes, little one, today you suffer so much they are going to declare it a national day of mourning.
  • Yes; your case is so important they are going to erect a statue to you.
  • In all the world no one suffers so much. What a crybaby you are!
  • Yes; you have just broken the world record for suffering and you have earned a cookie.

9. More examples that help toward healing?

  • Avoid drawing attention to oneself, as children do. Face unknown situations, something children do not like.
  • Avoid self-indulgence and coddling.
  • Seek to serve others, to come out of self-centeredness.
  • Remember divine filiation, finding thus a superior comfort that helps to reject lesser comforts.

E. Frequently asked questions

1. How to prevent homosexuality?

Homosexuality can be prevented by keeping in mind the way it is acquired. The following help to prevent it:
  • That parents try to be normal and take an interest in their children in the usual way, without excesses or absence.
  • That they treat their sons as males and their daughters as females. For example, boys tend to be more active and need to let off steam in physical activity. (This is why boys' schools spend more on maintenance and repairs than girls' schools.)
  • Training sons and daughters to lead a sacrificed life without feeling like victims. Not yielding to excessive complaints and coddling.
  • A correct, non-permissive sex education.
  • At school and in friendships: reject mockery about boys' manliness. Avoid the isolation of any one person.
  • Promote good humor and a healthy humility. Encourage a life of work and service to others.
  • Being self-demanding, training in effort and endurance. Flee from self-pity. Flee from continual complaining.
  • Nurture spiritual life, which will provide good support for any situation.

2. Are homosexuality and alcoholism comparable?

A person from Spain proposes this comparison, which is only valid in some respects:
  • Both alcoholics and homosexuals are human beings and deserve the corresponding respect. This does not mean that drunkenness and homosexual relations are correct. Understanding for persons must be shown, but not all human actions are good.
  • Both alcoholism and homosexuality are tendencies that should be controlled.
  • In both cases, if one gives in to the inclination, it becomes harder to control oneself on other occasions.

3. Is homosexuality a natural tendency?

It depends on what is meant by natural:
  • If natural is identified with spontaneous, then homosexuality can be called natural, and the same can be said of theft or murder when they arise from giving in to a tendency. In this sense it would have to be said that not everything natural — spontaneous — is correct. To avoid confusion, it is better in such cases to speak of spontaneous, reserving the term natural for the following.
  • If natural means something proper to human nature, then homosexuality is not a natural inclination, but a failure with respect to what is natural. What is natural in human sexuality is that a man marries his wife and they have children. If no children are born, something fails; if he unites with several women, something is not right; etc.

4. Is homosexuality a defect?

Homosexuality is an inclination opposed to what is natural in human sexuality, and therefore defective. Every person has various qualities and defects, so that having faults is normal; but defects are defects, not skills.

5. And gay pride?

Any pride is dangerous and harmful. Boasting about an unsolved problem does not solve the problem, but prevents the search for solutions. In this case, pride invites them to affirm themselves in actions that worsen their lives.

6. Could that pride not be a way to improve self-esteem?

They probably do it for this reason, since homosexuality includes an inferiority complex. But self-esteem is not improved by self-deception, but by acceptance of truth and effort to improve oneself. Firmness and constancy in self-mastery generate authentic satisfaction.

7. It is said that homosexuality is a defect and an illness. From Colombia they ask: is this hatred and discrimination? No, it is not. Saying that a person has defects or illnesses can never be discriminatory, since all human beings have them.

8. What does the Catholic Church say about homosexuality?

The Church distinguishes between persons and actions. It recommends understanding for persons, and at the same time warns that homosexual acts are gravely immoral. The same attitude is observed in the Church toward other incorrect behaviors of a sexual or any other kind: understanding for persons and firm clarity before errors, since it is not the same to act badly as to act well.

9. Where can homosexuality be treated?

There are many psychologists and psychiatrists who offer this service. Here are some links offering an overview of treatment: Note: Much of the article is based on this book: Van den Aardweg, Gerard J.M., "Homosexuality and Hope". This psychologist has cured nearly a hundred homosexuals.